⏰ Day 12 Warm-Up — Echo or New?

4 items · auto-graded

Academic Discussion is scored on contribution. Decide whether each response just echoes the students or adds a new angle.

Professor: Should cities invest more in public transport?
Student A: Yes — it reduces traffic and pollution.
Student B: But building it is very expensive.

Response 1

"I agree with Student A — public transport definitely reduces traffic and pollution."

Echo New angle

Echo — it just restates Student A's point.

Response 2

"While Student B is right about the cost, I'd add that good transport also boosts local businesses, since more people can reach shops and restaurants easily."

Echo New angle

New angle — acknowledges B, then adds an economic dimension neither student raised.

Response 3

"Both students make good points — transport is helpful but also costly."

Echo New angle

Echo — summarizing both sides with nothing new still caps your score.

Response 4

"A factor neither mentioned is accessibility: reliable transport helps elderly and disabled people who cannot drive, which is a matter of fairness."

Echo New angle

New angle — an equity/accessibility point that opens fresh ground.